ࡱ> %` R̻bjbjٕ2Szzzzzzz  +++++D@++++++++I@K@K@K@K@K@K@$AhTD:o@Ez,++,,o@zz++@???,z+z+I@?,I@??zz?++ -Cr+<?=@ @0@?Du?D??Dz!@+,?, ",+++o@o@?+++@,,,,h+$h+zzzzzz  NNgbag>kvSWelRg [eg2008-07-14] egn 0lf[xvz 02007t^,{6g0 \O[z_ Nge& [W[SO'Y -N \] 0Xd0wƋNCgSOS-Nv NNgbag>ke g;xzNvmgq_T _N gvQygvNb0V0e,g0'kv(W[ NNgbag>kvHeReǑ(uNW,gv Tvel sSN,c[SR Nv*NHhRg0[NЏ(uNWYNSWel:NW@xvwQSOĉR \[‰~Nm̀of0b/gSU\4ls^0^:W~gr`0Cg)R(ub,gI{V }{|WS0wQSOS ;NOTtSRۏLϑ OSwƋNCg?eV{TzN?eV{vSS0bV^S_u+R'`0WPtVYvbq~ Ne[U NNgbag>kvzlTgbl00 00 0sQ.͋0 NNgbag>kwƋNCgSOSSWelRg 0cke0 00N0 NNgbag>ki0 00 NNgbag>kSy:N N(uag>k(noNchallenge clauses or noNcontest clauses) /fcwƋNCgSOS-Nĉ[v O(uwƋNCgvSN N_[wƋNCgv gHe'`cQ(uvag>k00 00N(uW N w wƋNCgSOSSNR:N$N'Y{|b/g'`wƋNCgSOST^b/g'`wƋNCgSOS0(W^b/g'`wƋNCgSOSYFUhCg0W\OCgO(uSOS-N NNgbag>kvHeR(WSeS_NNKNW,geN [vQN;NSOT>yOteSOvq_T_N N'Y Vdk N/f,gev͑p0 b/g'`wƋNCgSOSSSN~R:NN)Rb/gWT^N)Rb/gWvSOS0^N)Rb/gWv NNgbag>kN\ N,Y_0RbTgbL0FO[N)Rb/gWv NNgbag>k TVR>PTN`uvQHeR \(W?eV{ N gf'Yv Nnx['`0 [1]Q N)Rb/gKNNvQNb/g[NVvybSU\4ls^T~NmSU\^vQ[\O(ufRf>f0:Ndk ,ge;NNN)Rb/gWv NNgbag>k:NOU\_00 00 NNgbag>kNuvwQSOSV gYy ibweg NYNN$N'Y{|vQN N)RCgN`]v)RvN[[ MNOSOSvb,g0(WN)R[g-N N/fǑ(ub__[g؏/f[([g NS[hQQnx0W[N)Rv gHe'`ZPQ[0SN8^ gEQv~NmR:gScbSfKNSsvSN)R'` [2]VdkN)RCgNvCg)RYN N3z[r` sSOTeglb&TNO(uNv_ NcQ_ew\Pbk/eNvO(u9_N g NVvΘi N)RCgNv~Nm)Rv_NS0RN_c1Y0Q N)Rɋ__c~e b,gؚf NNV:Nb gN)R1\N)RCgNQYdk'YvΘi >f6q NTt0vQN N)RCgNQN~cr`S0WMOv0[R1_\vSe__Ob_vQr`S[ev)RvS0ROr N/f NNgbag>kb:NvQ b&{ KNN0 YgN)RCgNb g:_'Yvb/gT~Nm[R (WvsQvWYN~[OR N)RO(uNwgQ_cQ(ubcQ(uvb,g_ؚ dke(WSOS-Nĉ[ NNgbag>kv;NvvR/f2bkSu܏g(u ~]vr`S[e)RvQR NN͑Oi00 00 1udkbNSN wQ NNgbag>kvQs gvQygvNb N/fOcꁫ)Rv[[؏/f~cr`S0WMO gN[vTt'`0FO/fُyKbkYg NS_0Wib _QNTttu _Ng gSdS:NWev]wQ0(W[ NNgbag>kvHeRTTl'`e Cgaُ$NyHegwQSORg00 00 N0 NNgbag>kS͑HegCgaǏ z-NvNk\O:NwƋNCgSOSvNR 6q^S0RwƋNCglvĉ6R0wƋNCg/fNyTlvWe Cg)RNvr`S0WMO_0Rl_vO06q YgN)RCgNvr`S z^QNObCg)RNv_ gb[N)RCgvn(u 1\[dkL:N͑e[Ɖ0(WOۏzNTcؚHes0ObyCgNOۏlQvvwv-N^S_YUOZPQCgaT b ُ/f Ne@wRSnv00 00 (N) NNgbag>kS bq_TvS͑'`0 00 NNgbag>k/fN)RCgN[Bl)Rv3z[vO Yg[T TSeuHe N)RCgN1\Og'Y0WQ\vQɋΘi fPNaN\vQN)RcCg~NNO(u cؚN)RvO(uHesN=\_V6eb,g0_v)R0 NΘib,gvQ\1\asT@wMNONSNvN)RO(u9 [NMNOb,g0Oۏm9y)R_N/f gvv0Ygl_%Nk uRSNSw`[N)Rv gHe'`cQ_ hbv~g/fN)Rvw['`_0RNO N&{TN)RagNvb/gۏNlQqQWOۏNb/gSU\FOvQmB\!kvTgtSS/fN)RCgNHN N?aa\N)RS~NNO(u N b1u][e HNSfN1\ N3uN)R Ǒ(uFUNy[I{vQNe_egObvQCg)R0FO[E N 1uNN)RCgN_Y`Q Nv^ NwQY[eN)RvgsOagN 1uvQ][eN)RHes Nؚ0jm9Dn [m9_N N)R0 FUNy[vObl ggP 1uN NlQ_ 1\NۏeQlQwW [>yOb/gۏekv!.s܏ NYN)R0Vdk Ttv0wfvP6RzN NN/fN)RCgNvFUN _N/f>yOb/gۏek0m9y)RcGSv00 00 N NvRg/f^z(WN)RCgNvCg)Rw[Tl l g[eWevaV NSN)RCgN(WvsQ^:W Nv^*g0RN[vƖ-N z^vMRcKN N0FO(WdkKNY bNv^ N&TNRN)RCgN ga)R(u NNgbag>kcpvQCg)RUtu u/fP6R0cdvsQWvb/gzN0Yg Nw[vN)R_0ROb SNT>yOlQO~~:N N_vWeN90GPYޏSNeR:YNN)R_vCg)R vQNN1\fl gR:gToRScQ_0ُ*NeP SN(WN[aIN N/f\O:NNlQqQ)RvvLO]wQ0sSO/fw[ gHevN)R _N NasT@wN)RCgN gĉ[ NNgbag>kvCg)R0V:NN)RI{Tl'`WeCg)RvSO(u NNNSmSSeS_NNv)Rv N[‰҉^ w[f/foR>yOybۏekT~NmSU\v gHe:g6R0 ~SfTR v)YMbkp0qmR)Rvvg V6q/f& Nmv}YV{ FOYgُy)RvvgSPNrv*NSOb\VSO Cg)RN[eT~cWevaV_N gS NNgbag>kvygHeg,kċNǏ z-NvNkq_TvS͑'` [vQۏLċNeNS͑vNyOlQs^01uvzNy^:Nvh0Nzl'`( w wƋNCgl/fyl N*NNv1uCg)R:N9h,gRNpzNlSOsNV[lQCgR[yWzNsQ|vNN N>yOۏekTlQqQ)Rv:NaϑckS_'`vhQ wQ g:Nf>fvlQl'`00 00ُN]_uQz[(S fNyr[`Q NyN"NCgT>yOlQqQ)Rvvwv FOُ*Nwvv^^/f NSTv0 T7h N)RlTzNl(WwƋNCgST TW_NX[(WN'`01990t^vV Atari Games Corp.v.Nin-tendo of American Inc.Hh-N l[(W$RQ-NcQ N)RCgTSXbbelvvhMN wwegkۏLċNe HQ~bQ$NyNkvċN/f^8^ *N'`S vǏ z $NyNkۏLSWelċNvyrk̀of0 00WN N TV` TV?e^[VYRTOۏRe0Ob]NbDTVEzNOR OۏewƋ Od0oR*gegReI{~NN N T z^v͑Ɖ0SShf (W:ONVEhQe YSV[/f9hnc,gVSU\vǑ~^vQSU\4ls^vOb!j_0 Te gnchf N)R6R^b[OۏSU\Tb/g Odnx g.^R NVv;NSvegnN[T,gVvOb!j_v1u b0 [4](WNLu~NmNwƋ\O:NSU\RRvN)Y TVe N\ObwQ gkORvwƋNCg\O:NvQzN?eV{v 0 dN\pe8h_b/gReV YV0e,g0'kV[KNY vQNV[yr+R/fSU\-NV[vMR;N/f_ۏTc^eb/g ;NReR؏ NNMRba0Vdk (W:ONReRvV[ Rb/gOo`vAmR[Vb/gR^v.^R܏uNUS~:_SwƋNCgOb0 [5]ddkKNY ُNV[b0W:S(WNzN?eV{҉^YtwƋNCgebO6qX[(W͑v]+R ُN]+ReuNvQzNl_bwƋNCgl_NSvQ]NT^:W~gv]+RT|(WNw0 [6]0 00bV/fNLu;Nvb/g_ۏVKNN }6qN܏v?eV{>PT N wbNN[W{Q;NReR FO/f\O:NSU\-NV[ vMRbVwƋNCg?eV{v@wkvSWel[ge gsQS_@\v`^1\ NHN:_lxT%NkZPQYOS0VdkSWe:gsQ[dk'YSNKb NYu` AQN[VQvꁛRQeNmvCg)R0 [7]N[ N sSON gCg)Rn(uKNZvORe6R[v NNgbag>k _N N_6q[zNy^ b[(Z _NsS NNgbag>k N/f,gݏlv ^wQSORgvQ[vsQ^:Wvq_T0;N{:gsQS g(WRg NNgbag>k;xzNvs[HegT MbS[vQ\OQSWelaIN Nv[00 00 N0 NNgbag>kSWelĉ6RvVYzl[0 00 (N)TV[ NNgbag>kvwQSOĉ[0 00 1.VzNlW[wƋNCgSOSĉ6Rv|~f/fVSl萌TT8fYXTON1995t^4g6eTT^v 0wƋNCgyrOS-NvSXbbecWS 0(N N{y 0cWS 0)0 0cWS 0ĉ[Nċ0OwƋNCgSOS-NP6R'`cevFhg~gSSXbbevRg!j_0[cQ gNP6R'`cevQ'`(N_6q~g_>f6q/f;xzNv Vdk^S_\[N w\O/f,gݏlN N~cvzُNP6R'`ce[zNSNuvq_THeg kYV[Nk^S_Ǒ(uUOySRۏLRg lb(W$R[eS0RT?eV{v:_'Yq_T0e(WW TvLear Inc.v.AdkinsHh-N gؚlb1\]~nx[ TN)R?eV{vCgZؚN]T TlvW@xSR0 [9]0 00 N20N~+gN VvSU\?eV{/f=\S0WOۏReTb/gieNOczNR R N NNgbag>kv^ N_6qOzNS0R NTtv[(_c[ vMR:NNva/f N\ NNgbag>kƉ:N,gݏl /f(uTtSRRNRg0Ygag>kOۏNzN cؚNzNHes 1\^S__0R/ec0 [10]0 00 2._VSWelv;N nn/fS[P6RzNl vQ-N,{17ag(ST T);N(uNb/g'`wƋNCgvlTSOS0,{17ag,{1>kĉ[NSR N NAQwƋNCgCg)RN\OQQObCgQ[vP6R,{2>kR>NNNN_0RAMQvP6R'`ce  SُNP6Rl gQ@b_bSvObCgv gHeg ,{2>k,{3ysS:N NAQ[SvObCgcQ_ 0ُasT@w NNgbag>k(W_Vfnx_0RNSWelvAMQ NƉ:NQwƋNCgCg)RvP6R0 [11]0 00 3.e,gybkyNWeSnxOlQckNfl,{23agĉ[ ,glĉ[ N(uN:N/fLOW\OCgl0N)Rl0[(ueWl0Y‰lbFUhlĉ[vCg)RvL:N0 ُ7h wƋNCgvWeckS_'`(We,gl_ N_0RNfnxnx0FO/f ckS_Cg)Rv NS_LO_NSO[zNNuP6R01999t^7g30e e,glQckNfYXTO^N 0N)RTknowNhowSOS-NvSWelc[e 0(N N{y 0c[e 0) vQ,{NRN9hncybkWel,{23ag[N)RSOSĉ[vʑ,{ NR/fN[8fv NTtP6RTyNWe҉^ wN)RTknowNhowSOS,{VR N NlQck8f[v҉^ wN)RTknowNhowSOSv‰p -N,{3p P6RT#N fnxcQNĉ[ N_(uN)R gHe'`ag>kvTg0ybkSN(uN)R gHe'`vN)RSOS\Ɖ:N NlQs^vNfL:NT[SWelvݏS MRc/fُyybkOSe~cN,g N^_N)RvCg)Rv^[^:WzNNuN N)Rvq_T0ُ*N‰p(WknowNhowSOS-N_N T7h(u YgSvknowNhow]~/flQwv0 [12]0 00 N 0c[e 0SN wQ e,g\ NNgbag>kƉ:NgN`Q N^\N NlQckNfL:NTݏlvP6R'`ce [vQOwQSO`QۏLċ0O Hhnx[0;`SO e,gvĉ[{|kĉ[ TbXTeSN(WNOSvvQNĉ[NvMRc N 9hncbXTVv gsQl_Tĉz ǑSS_ce6Rbkbc6RNSgbn(uwƋNCg0[^:WzNNu N)Rq_TvzT TvZPlbagN kY r`S'`VcagN0ybk[wƋNCgv gHe'`cQ(uvagN0:_'`vNcP[S00 00 TRIPSOSvĉ[k<{~ ;N/fcCgvQbXTS9hnc,gV[T0W:Sv[E ĉ[(Wyr[`Q Ngb[wƋNCgvn(u0[zN g N)Rq_TvZPlbagN vQ-N [ NNgbag>kۏLċ$RsS/fcCgvQ[KNN0 yr[`Q v(uhf TRIPS[dk(uv/fTtSR [ NNgbag>k/f&Tݏl9hncwQSO`QRg0 [13]0 002.'kvzNlv[SOĉgƖ-N0WSOs(W 0^z'k2mqQ TSOag~ 0(sS 0Wlag~ 0)v,{3agT,{81082ag ُNĉR\O:N2bkwƋNCgNn(uvQCg)RvW@x02004t^4g27e 'kqQSOYXTO^N 0sQNb/glOS(uag~,{81ag,{3>kv772/2004SagO 0(CONMMISSION REGULATION (EC)No.772/2004 of 27 April 2004 on the Application of the Article 81(3) of the Treaty to Categories of Technology Transfer Agreement) {y:NTTBE ,geN N{y 0772/2004SagO 0)0 0772/2004SagO 09eSN1996t^1g31e'kvYXTOS^v 0b/glT TƖSO(u'kvag~,{81(3)agv,{240/96SagO 0(N N{y 0240/96SagO 0)-Nўrag>k0}vrag>kTpprag>kvR{| ǑSNy [lv0OrSO| vAMQeHh S/fĉ[NSNAMQv [hQ/n (safe harbor)T NSNAMQv%N͑P6RzNvag>k(hardcore restriction) ddkKNY(WN[v^:WNKNQ [14]@b g N/ff>fybkvP6R/fAQv0 0772/2004SagO 0,{5agR>NN(W,{81ag,{3>kKN N*NHhċ0Ov [hQ/n KNYvL:NTag>k vQ,{1>kSb NNgbag>k FOP[:Nl g_c[SN(WSN(uSN)Rv gHe'`e~bkSvCg)Rv NNgbag>k0ُNĉ[\ NNgbag>kN 0240/96SagO 0vўrag>k-NTRd }6q_N\vQcd(WAMQVKNY FO/fag>k NOq_Tb/glT TvQNRvHeR NvQ[zN/f&TNu[(q_T_N*NHhċ0O0 [15]0 00( N)\~Nċ0 001uNwƋNCgW)Rvv YBg'` TRIPSOS\[ NNgbag>kwQSOĉ[vCg)RKNNTbXT SVE'`B\bv~Nzlb1\ N'Y0S‰TVQT:SW'`zl R/fRSU\ ΘǑTHT0V0e,g0'kvI{(W[ NNgbag>kvĉ6R N g_YqQ Tyr_vQN /fNkbqvSWel:NW@x (WwƋNCgSOSP6R'`ag>kvwQSOĉR-Nĉ[ NNgbag>kvvQN /f1uL?e:gsQ6R[c[e'`(vagO ĉ6R!j_vL?e'`ri_kf>fvQS Ǒ(uN{|WSvRgel \q_T NNgbag>k[vV }wQSO~S vQ-Nyr+R͑Ɖ[^:WV }vRgvQV (Wĉ[N,SRvW@x N fRl͑)R(uYt^Sl[~vy/}ۏL*NHhRgvQN [wƋNCg?eV{TzN?eV{SSvOe^_ؚ [-N Ne\OQv^vO9e gfR[~g0up;mvR00 00ddkKNY (W[ NNgbag>kwQSOvĉ6RǏ z-N TV[T0W:S_NX[(W@w]+R0kYV gTtSRT,gݏlSRv:SR gbl:gsQ(W$Re NNgbag>kHeRvǏ z-N g'Yv1uϑCg0ُNyr_}6qwQ g_wS_NN_tg N3z[vRR tSSwQYN[e^Rup;m$RevOp ُ_Nck/fV1995t^ 0cWS 0SeASYt^N6q*g\OO9evyKN@b(W0'kv2004t^[vQ19%t^^v 0240/96SagO 0-N NNgbag>kvĉ[\ONO9e 9eSNǏS[ NNgbag>kv~[['` 1ueHev ўrag>k S:N*NHhċ0O['`0ُ^NwƋNCg?eV{TzN?eV{[~gSv FO;`SO gbl:gsQvϑCgKNVS0RNf'Yv~_g N gRN'kvQNSOSvvh0 [16]_Vvĉ[{USfnx vc\ NNgbag>k~NSWelvAMQVKNQ SُNP6Rl gQCg)Rv gHeg0NbKN-NmS͑Rv_V:NN=\_0Wb` YTSU\~Nm (WzNl gS0R[('`_c[vMRc N  WNcRTOۏb/gl [gNn(ub/g'`wƋNCgP6RzNvL:NZPQ[_b􋩋ek [17]NsS=\S0W(uAMQve_OCg)RN\OQvP6RTlS NNgbag>k1\/fNُye_S_NTlN0ُN*N'`Sveu(Wc-NV wƋNCgSOS-N NNgbag>kv$R[S0RNV[‰?eV{0SS̀of0~NmrQ0^:W~gI{YebV }vq_T Np{US TNSvS00 00V0 NNgbag>kSWelċNǏ z-N8^v N'Y:S0 00(N) NNgbag>kN[ݏSNSeva?aNNNT TSev1ua?aeg wƋNCgSOS-NvSe_Y`Q N NN[/f돥cS NNgbag>k0YgSevCg)Rr` N3z[ _6qOXRSevwƋNCgO(u9N\O:NΘibO0 gvS_NRSNS/f`/eN9(uO(ub/g NNv^ N`9e0|RTёScbSevCg)R kzُ N/f MQ9vHS 0\O:Nt'`v~NmNyr+R/fN%)R:Nvvv~%OEQRƋ0RSQsv~NmHe^ u N~~O(uywƋNCgvTg0(WSeYN~Nmbb/gv1_R0WMOe NN@bsQlvS/fYUOO(uSO(uvb/gg'YP^0W%)R0ُy`b_ NSe/f?acSOS-Nv NNgbag>k [vsQ^:WvzN NONu[('`q_T00 00 (N) NNgbag>kvċNǏ zSsQl[zNvq_T}6q NN[[zNNu[('`q_T FO@b gv NNgbag>kbYb\[zN gN[vP6R ;N{:gsQQv/fُNP6R'`ce/f&TO[zNNu[('`v;x0HQ ;N{:gsQ$ReُNP6R'`ce/f&T/f:NON)RCgNvbP0OۏN)R[eTt_{v0vQ!k Yg/fTt_{v ;N{:gsQ\(W[OۏN)R[evHescؚN;xzNSU\HegKNۏLCga NQ[(WvsQ^:W N[zNSNuvQ\O(u0;xzNvHegf>f ;N{:gsQfvHescؚv z^ؚ0Q!k sSO0Rؚ z^vHescؚ_N NasT@wN[_0RzNlvAMQ /f&TX[(W[ESLv0P6R'`ĉ[f\vfNeHhNQ[gNP6R'`ce/f&TTt_/f gN[ z^sQTv0Yg>f fS_NeSNǏf\P6R'`ĉ[vceeg0R{|kCgavǏ zNt NSNR:NN NQ*Nek ُ_N/fV(uTtSRċ0OwƋNCgSOSvN,'`el0(WċNǏ z-NEQRQHescؚvbt1u0S_6q [ TNSOS-Nv NNgbag>kTVS\OQ N Tv[ k*NV[vwQSO^:WsX0N)RTwƋNCg?eV{0~Nm~gI{Sq_T[[HescؚTzN z^v[00 00 ( N)[ NNgbag>kHeRv[N$[0 00 V[ NNgbag>kv[ g'Yv Nnx['` gV[ĉ[sSO&{TAMQvhbagN YvQTgݏSNAMQvRw ;N{:gsQ_NSNdAMQ0'kv 0772/2004SagO 0,{6agĉ[ Yg'kvYXTO(WNUO`Q NSs(uMRAMQvb/glOSwQ g g`N 0Wlag~ 0,{81ag(3)vHeg RvQ gCgd,gagO(uKN)Rv0 [19]dNlbQ[vS Y S_NN_NS(WwɋTbT0ُelb/f&TZWc~~[g?VSl[-NvZPl/fb1ulbcQv^ Tav0㉳QN)R~~vOS/fSN:_6RgbLv0 LearHhKNNN)RSNTl Nv& & eSs@bSN)Rv gHe'`v4OCg)R NSOS-N/f&TSb NNgbag>k06q LearHhv^^l gP6R Sg͑KNY(WNLearHhv?eV{ =\{:_ gR FO(W/ecɋ?aT㉹ebv^ NQ~NN,?eV{ĉ[KN N0 [20]=\{wƋNCg?eV{TzN?eV{wQ gSmSvlQqQ)Rvvri_ FO/fS_NNv?aTCg)RS/fS0RP6Rv^l geR:Y \(WV]~ۏNSl[g z^v NNgbag>kHhN(Wlb Tav`Q NN6q/fSdVv0S_6q S_NNKNvT}6q[Se g)R FOvQ N)RvTg__1ute*N>yObb VdkbVs6k/f&TbS_NNTNۏNekFUi00 00 N0 NNgbag>kċNV }v['`Rg  NSWel:NƉ҉0 00 Nt N ċNSOS-NP6R'`cev[E~Nmq_TSvQTl'` lb_{CgaT TP6R(WoRReebv>yO6evN(W;bkzNebv>yOb,g0S gُ7h lbMb[uHhN((Wُ{|HhN-N SXbbe?eV{NwƋNCg?eV{NvQz)\OQNSXbbeTwƋNCgv?eV{W@xvNv$RQ0 [21]s(WbN@bvg:NsQ. sSlbvCgael0b,gNHevv~Nmf[RgelNhb w/fgT0g gStv FO/fvsQv>yOb,gT6evvwQSOSϑvMR؏l_0RN􁤋 T S_MR~Nmf[yvsrO_ُyċ0O^8^V0N)RoR&^egv>yO6ev/f Nnx[v NUONelcON)RoRg:NTvLuP(oRǏϑboR NY N&^egHevvg'YS)0 T7h nx[ NNgbag>k[zNvP6RHeg_N/fNy܏*g[bvNR0sSOR:_Ǒ(uNُy&^ g Nnx['`v~Nmf[Rgel vQ-N YBgT|~v{_N_(WSl[-NЏ(u0ՋVRg@b gvSϑ [vQ;xzNToRRevwQSOϑۏLCga 1\Y T(u{:g z^egQ[ɋ~gN7h NR[E0 [22] 00 NSl[ w NNgbag>kHeRv[[TV/f^8^hKbvNyNR0kYV1ulb(W*NHh-NǑ(uTtSRۏLRg 1uN~NmSU\b_R0TN)R?eV{0^:WzNsXCNNl[*NN>PTv N T SU\QN|Rv$RO [sLearHhv$RQ~gn\O@wOck01982t^V^zN蕡[tN)RHhNvT]V Nɋlb ǑSN[N)R@b gNf#NvZPl NY(WLearHhq_T N@b\O$RQ-NnxzvHhOl0 [23](We,g wƋNCgSOS8^(WuHeMRcNlQckNfYXTO(JFTC)YHh _eJFTCSNۏLzNlv[g0}6qe,g[wƋNCgSOS-NP6R'`ag>kvzlĉ[k%NkHeRvzlĉ[k<{~ 1uN g1uϑV }vX[(W (WgblǏ z-N T7hb4N@wY Nnx['`0 NeN1\Sq_T;N{:gsQۏLCgavV }\ONN['`Rg N\O:N[ NNgbag>kHeRvS00 00 (N)[‰sXeb0 00 1.NVvN)Rb/gT~NmSU\rQ0 00 sNhQt'`zNOR_'Y z^ NSQNb/g0elievzޘsۏ O~V }OY"[0S_vD,gT6qDn@bwv\O(ueg\ VdkNLuTVzvǑSTye_OcTcؚꁫvybzNR0N, SV[/fsNyf[b/gv;NbDVTNQV vQN)RCgOb4ls^ؚSU\-NV[;N:NHQۏb/gv_ۏV vQN)ROb4ls^v[NO :NNON_ۏYVHQۏb/gSU\,gV~Nm SU\-NV[_N N?aǑ(uؚvOb4lQ Nُ_NO~vQ bl͑v"?eb0 [25]V0'kvI{b/gHQۏ0~NmSvV[Nvkl͑\wƋNCg\O:Ny g"NegOb SCg)RvO(ul g[>yOzNy^ b'YvZ l_1\ NZPr^m [NN)RSOS-N NNgbag>kv`^_N/fYdk0FO/fSU\-NV[fRPw>yO~NmvteSOSU\ >PTN6R[N*N[lvN)RCgn(uvV 1u;N{:gsQN>yOۏek:N[TۏL[0S f(W[ NNgbag>kHeRv[ N b/gHQۏ0~NmSvV[__ g:Nbqvl_ O~T~ ;N{:gsQ[evhQf:N0N[TQnx0 SU\-NV[vsQvl_lĉ N/f_ePhQ ;N{:gsQSl:ON[ SS6RNꁫ~NmSU\v [ NNgbag>kv[X[(WfY Nnx['`V }00 00 2.6R[lĉev?eV{̀of0 00 zNlS?eV{vq_T^8^f>f kY'kv(W20N~90 x z VXPRtvnp!!!!%%l(n(((((L,N,\-^- //223333557 7<<<<??DDNDPDFFJK0K2KDOFOOORRVVVVWWZZ[[J[h mm2m4mNmPmUhL hLo(`6 > v x z VXPRtvgdL̻np!!!!%%l(n(((((L,N,\-^- //2233335gdL557 7<<<<??DDNDPDFFJK0K2KDOFOOORRVVVVgdLVWWZZ[[ mm2m4mNmPm*p,pFpHpZr\rxrzrttttuuwwwgdLt^NSsvQ(WQS^:WvN0xvz_STReebvzN0WMOv[NVTe,gegS0RNJR1_ N/fQ[ǑS_ceOۏyf[b/gvxvz_S]\O v^:NONyr+R/f-N\ONKNvb/glcOO)R0(Wdk̀of N'kv19%t^^N 0240/96SagO 0 fnxĉ[Nb/glT Tag>kvAMQ ib'Y}vrnUSV )\ўrnUSV0 [26]FO/fُNagOǏNb__;NINTRlx dNfnxĉ[vAMQT'kvYXTOv*NHh[gY P6R'`ce_ N0RAMQ0@bN'kvYXTOzNc[YMRYAlexander Schaub\agOc:NNS I{_mp~vP` 0 [27]2001t^12g 'kvYXTOS^NNNċ0ObJT lQ_b 0240/96SagO 0v:w v^b\O6R[evf:Nyg0f:N1uT^z(W~NmRgW@x Nvb/glĉR0N/f2004t^4g27e 'kqQSOYXTO^N 0772/2004SagO 00agOib'YNĉR(uvSOSvV Sm Nr nUSNKNNf:N[lvAMQ0ُNxQWvSU\Ǐ zS fQ'kvv?eV{lS 'kvNMRb_b/glT T-NvP6R'`ag>kO[zNNuP6R'`Tg s(WR:N V:Nb/glYQ\xS Nv͑ Y0X:_W@xxSvRR0:RoRevXR0OOb/gvibceTR'YNTv^:WzN Vdkb/glOS8^Ocؚ~NmHesTOۏzN 0 [28] N Tv?eV{>PT[Nlĉv]_TSR Vdk NNgbag>k(W N TV[0u TNV[v N TegSHeR N T0;`SO S_cؚHesvBl'YN[P6RzNvP``e NNgbag>kfS_0R[_00 00(N)SOSv_‰̀ofeb0 001.^:W~gvrQ0 00^:W~g/fcwƋNCgSOS@bmSvvsQLNv^:WrQ ;Nc^:WƖ-N^0~Nmĉ!jTۏNXWI{0^:WƖ-N^/fc^:WNc6R(W\pe'YONKb-Nv z^ [/fS fyr[^:WzNTWe z^vN*NW,gi_0Yg&^ g NNgbag>kvSOS/f1uc6R^:WNv\pe'YON\O:NSe vQ1\ g_f>fv~cWevaV0~Nmĉ!j/fcvsQLN-NONvĉ!j N TLNvyr'`Q[NvQ-NONvƖ-NbRce z^0~Nmĉ!j'YvON@b6R[v NNgbag>k[vsQ^:WvzNrQf[fNuq_T @bN^S0RSWelf:N%Nk_NSb:N] gON;xeONۏNvXWKNN0QNeb/g=\_ۏNlQqQW OcLNS_zN'`vQ NNgbag>kvHeR^\NSWelϑvV00 002.vsQ^:WvLu[0 00vsQ^:Wv[sQ|0R^:W/eMRTWe z^v[ vsQ^:W\ wƋNCgN_0RfN NNgbag>k(WvsQ^:WvP6RzNR1\'Y0wƋNCgSWvvsQ^:WLu[;NQvsQb/g^:WTvsQNT^:W SbSfN'`b/gT N8nvSfN'`NT0Ygg*NWwQ g~[vb/gN g'` (Ws(WTNTvS_NkeQvQN;NSONۏN Sl g[ESLv'`T~Nm NTtvfN'`NT HN[ُNWb/gSOS-N NNgbag>k$\vQ(Na0ُy NNgbag>kg gS/fVek\vN)RCgN~cꁫWe0WMOvKbk /fNNQN[eb/gTeNTvOu` \OvNHQ200 003.[Cg)Rv(ub,g0 00[ gt'`vSNeg SO(u9(u\Nɋb,gTS1YSvbD0S/eNv_c[TPё(Q%ɋQs)KNT NNOؚtQNk Nrk0W/eNO(u90 N$NKNv]'Y zN gS bNQO(u9 NNSNQv_NOY0 [29]ُe[E Nv NSNgb]~mSNT T-N NNgbag>kvSzN'` V:NsSOl g NNgbag>kvĉ[_Ng gS0R;bkSN(uv T7hHeg0ُev NNgb N/f1uNn(uN^:Wbb/gOR [hQ/f1uCg)R(uvvsQV }Q[0NSR N ُy^:_Rb_bv NNgbHeg NSSWelvĉ6R0S g(WCg)Rv(ub,g\e N6qՋVǏ NNgbag>kcd(uvS'`vL:NMb^S0RSWelYvsQl00 00( N)SOSvꁫ }eb0 001.NfSeS_NNvsQ|0 00'kv 0772/2004SagO 09hnc(WvsQNT^:WTvsQb/g^:W NvsQ| \SOS~:SR:NzNKNvOST^zNKNvOS v^N(WR>N[('`P6RzNag>kTAMQag>ke_N/fR+Rĉ[0zNKNvSOSS0RzNlf:N%Nk_0RAMQSf:NV0V 0wƋNCgyrOS-NvSXbbecWS 0,{3.3_Nĉ[N[gOSS_NNKNvsQ|;N/f*jTsQ|؏/f~TsQ| bbNGW g0*jTsQ|,gv^ NfSOS[cwQ gSzN'` ~TsQ|_N NN[O_[OۏzNvSU\0FO(WvQNV }v Tv`Q N N~TsQ|vk *jTzNKNwƋNCgST T-Nv NNgbag>kfSOXRce^:WzNvΘi0ُ$N*NOfNSeS_NNKNvwQSOsQ|`R/f[ NNgbag>k[v͑aϑV }KNN00 00 2.SeS_NNv^:W0WMO0 00 N,v;N‰vɉObNN:NwƋNCgST T-NSe;`/fYN1_R 돥cSb/g:_Rev NlQs^agN0[E N  \ON0R^zv]ST*NN/fxQWvDё NvSe NNkYSe gf\vDnTN؏NvR0NN[~Nm/fsQ͑v l_vOb0l_^S_Q0RُN\bDck(WbNYg͑vb/gWb:N[ 0 [30] NNgbag>k/fُN1_RvSeObꁫCg)R ^ BlT~cWe0WMOvKbk V:N[R:_'YvSeNQk'Yvb,gScbSevwƋNCg0ُy`b_ N NNgbag>k_S NwQ gbS g_\v;xzN'`0SKN YgSeYN~Nm0b/g NvOR0WMO uN(Wyr[LNb gvS_N cgqSWelĉ6R[`Svt_1\f^S0R[g00 00 3.SOSv{|W0 00 N,vb/gSOS-NSeS/f:NO(ur`S'`vb/gN9 (WuN~%-N[[RN)R(u qQ T/eM^:WvS_NNKNzvNSSOS0:Nzb/gTT zvSOS0wƋNCgƖTSOSI{ gb/gFc~vri_0YgOS-NS g NNgbag>k vNKN[[evb/g NR(u _S[eb/gvc^O(u bx &^egvsQb/gV[\Pn0YO(uNiǏؚvTg01uN{|OSSmSYe;NSO [vsQ^:Wv^:W/eMRT^:WNvq_TN,'YNSe;NSOvOS0{|SOSvSWelAMQ'YS%NkۏL[ge_Nu_:N%Nkv gHegP0 00 [ NNgbag>kv gHegPĉ[ N T O[(uCg)R gHe'`v:gOb,g bq_T0 gHegPĉ[_ SN[Cg)RcQ(uv;x'YSKN R\09hnc NNgbag>k gHegPwv N T 'YSO g NyS'`0,{Ny/f NNgbag>kv gHegQNwƋNCgvX[~g wQ gf>fv NTt'` W,g NS_0RAMQ0,{NyS'`/f NNgbag>kv gHeg(WSvwƋNCgX[~gQ FO/fQNSOSv gHeg0(WCg)RvO(ugQSN\ gO(u)Rv YyN N_(uCg)RvINR Ng*N҉^ w/fNyCg)RTINRvs^aKbk0YgSN NQO(uywƋNCge_NBl N(uCg)Rv gHe'` ُyBll glaSeS_NNKNv)Rvs^a fS/fSeOR0WMOvn(u0؏ gNyS/f NNgbag>kv gHegel gQwƋNCgv gHeg_Nl gQSOSvX[~g0ُy NNgbag>kgPvTt'`}N;N{:gsQ[ FOWN[[vsQ^:Wvq_TffTc6R [Cg)RN~Nm)RvvOnx gTtKNY Vdk_0RAMQvS'`g'Y00 00 mQ0bV NNgbag>kvzl[ NN9eۏ0 00 (N)bV NNgbag>kzlsrċg0 00bVT Tl,{329agĉ[ ^lWeb/g0Yxb/gۏekbO[NNb/gbgvb/gT TeHe0 2005t^1g1euHev 0gؚNllbsQN[tb/gT T~~HhN(ul_r^vʑ 0,{10ag,{6yĉ[  ybkb/gcSe[T Thvb/gwƋNCgv gHe'`cQ_b[cQ_DRagN v`b_ ^\NT Tl,{329ag@byv ^lWeb/g0Yxb/gۏek 00 002004t^4gO9ev 0-NNSNlqQTV[Y8fl 0X,{Nz N[Y8f gsQvwƋNCgOb 0z,{30ag[VEwƋNCgST T-NwƋNCgSN^:WWe0WMOvn(uL:NۏLNSR'`vĉ[ sS wƋNCgCg)RN g;bkSN[ST T-NvwƋNCgv gHe'`cQ(u ۏL:_6R'`NcP[S (WST T-Nĉ[cNTԏcagNI{L:NKNN v^qS[[Y8flQs^zNy^v VRb[Y8f;N{SNǑS_vcemdqSi 00 00N:Npe NYvĉ[-NbNSN wQ bV[X[(W NNgbag>kvVQb/gT Tvc[:NeHe v^N:Nĉ[ NNgbag>k/f ^lWeb/g vL:N0[VEwƋNCgST T-N g NNgbag>kv^ qS[[Y8flQs^zNy^v [Y8f;N{MbSNǑSce SVEwƋNCgST T-Nv NNgbag>k NN[ݏSzNl ;N{*NHh[00 00 HQ ُ$NYvĉ[ǏN!j|0[VQvwƋNCgSOSNi[:NeHe(WSl[vd\O-NV6q{US FO NNgbag>k/f&TX[(W[zNv[(;xSYV }q_T zNl?eV{_NY(W NeteKN-N ُy NRR vZPlMQ g1YlQAQ0[VEwƋNCgSOSvĉ[1\fNNIcxd dN[lv qS[[Y8flQs^zNy^ vMRc R N~NVRb[Y8f;N{ ǑS_cemdqSi vCgRY l gNUOSN[Ed\OvhQT z^0S[Y8flvzlvv1\/fKN;N{:gsQ VRb[Y8f;N{[ NNgbag>kI{P6R'`cevQSlCg FO/f sQN[Y8f;N{蕄vQSlCgYUOLO ޏW,gv z^'`ĉ_Nl g00 00 vQ!k bVzl:SRVQwƋNCgSOSTVEwƋNCgSOS-Nv NNgbag>kl g_ /fl_(u-Nv NlQs^sa0sQNbVzl-Nv QY g+R 0 Vl_G sae]_w>yOTLuvY^ NNgbag>kvzl_Nl g1NُNOWY0vQ[ N/f,gV؏/fYVvwƋNCg ScCgNN(W,gVO(u 1\S[,gVv^:W bq_T 1\^S_S0R,gVzNlv TI{[g0YgbN[S+T NNgbag>kvVQwƋNCgST TNi[:NeHe eu[bNVQb/gvvN_ۏTO(u N)R0[NVEwƋNCgSOS 1uNbV/fNLu N;Nvb/g_ۏV NNgbag>kS;N/fP6R\O:NSevbVS_NNv)Rv Vdk$NKNvs^a_bc KN;N{:gsQN[v1uϑCg/f^8^_v0v[ [Y8flvĉ[:NTt VQlvvsQĉ[Ndk~N \OQv^vO9e00 00 Q!k bV[ NNgbag>kvĉ[ceNpe*Nl_ĉKN-N0NT TlTgؚNllbvSlʑ w  ^lWeb/g0Yxb/gۏek v NNgbag>keHe /fǑ(uNb/gSU\\O:N$RehQ0FO/f[Y8flSfnxĉ[N NNgbag>k qS[[Y8flQs^zNy^v 1u;N{:gsQǑSce /fǑ(uNzNy^\O:N$RehQ0b/gSU\TzNy^hQKNNNv/f*NN㉳Qv bV(W[ NNgbag>kvl_ĉ6R-NǑSN$Ny N Tvt\S fNzl,g(WW,gz:W N1\X[(W NN0 zNNSU\(W; Nv^ NX[(W NSTvwv (WSU\-NzNv^(WzN-NSU\ ُ/fb/gNuSvQ^(u(W^:WS!j_ Nv^ g_0 [31]FO/f ; NvSN~Nv^ NasT@wzlb/g NSNv^L (W[ NNgbag>kaϑvǏ z-NvzzUONSRf:NOHQSvcq_T@w$Re~g0Q Yg1ugbl:gsQ(WwQSOvHhO-NbcW,gvSR MQOQs1YT N~N [HhN~gTS_NN_tgv Nnx[00 00 (N)[bV NNgbag>kl_ĉ6Rv^0 00 1.bVvyrkV`Q[N N{USgq,dVYv~0 00 V0'kv0e,gI{[ NNgbag>kvvsQzlk[Y N g@w0N[vSl[~ bV(W^z NNgbag>kvĉ6RSO|vǏ zKN-N_[fS0R NHQۏV[vq_T0ُNbRvxQy i0R-NV/f&TO6q g:_vvu}TR v^NS%cvQS gvRHebT?HQ ُNV[vSWel]~ gN N~vt^vSS [-Nb_bNkbqvzlTgblSO| bV(WvsQebv~y/}k1_ >yOlQOvcS z^_N g_W{Q0vQ!k eV[SWelvQSN'YuN_Sv~Nmؚ^Ɩ-N ~NmǏ^Rce/fbVvMR~NmrQv;Ne_0bVSWelSOs~Nm~g0~NmSU\ĉRTNN?eV{v MQQsgbL-Nĉ!j~NmTSbQWev$N b0Q!k bVvMR/f;Nvb/gۏSV ^b/gR V Vdkl_ĉ6Rvvh/fOۏb/gvAmlTO(u0k b/gHQۏveV[f>PTN~bb/gR v;N[eOR yr+R/f@wV0e,gI{V(W O~6R WORv'N1Y wƋNCgXWb:NُNV[N:Y^:WORvV{eu0N NYv]_Q[NeHQۏV[vl_~v^ NwQ gnf'` sSONt N wُNl_6R^&{T^:W~NmlQs^0HesvW,gBl {USy i_N_ gS_w4lW N g00 00 2. N[SWelggǏؚ0 00 bVs(WsQN NNgbag>kvzl\ ba _YN[ ^gNSWel[wƋNCgSOS-NvP6R'`ag>k\O:N~vRg02007t^8g30eASJ\hQVN'Y8^YO,{NAS]N!kOǏv 0-NNSNlqQTVSWel 0,{55agĉ[ ~%Ogq gsQwƋNCgvl_0L?elĉĉ[LOwƋNCgvL:N N(u,glFO/f ~%n(uwƋNCg cd0P6RzNL:N (u,gl0 ُNagsQNwƋNCgWevĉ[^8^ba l gR>NQwQSOvy{| Sl[-N_bc0bN:NvQ-N gzl:wvV } FO_N N_Ɖ NNgbag>k,gyr_v6R~0YMR@b q_T NNgbag>kHeRvV }_ YBg :NǏNSWel1\㉳Q@b g/f NR[Ev0bVSWel^ OY zlTgbl~\Em sSO(W gNvS_bqvSWel~vVT'kv _N/fǏwQSOv[ec[ĉReg%_eSWezlv N0Vdk bVSWel_NSĉ[[wƋNCgST T-NvP6R'`ag>kۏLzNlRgvW,gSRTN,$RehQ Ndk\O:N[ NNgbag>kHeRvc[ N[ NNgbag>kHeRvwQSO$ReǏ z 1uvQNvl_ĉTSl[egeEQ00 00 3.bV NNgbag>kl_[vW,g`0 00 (1)SWezl NkXezz}v0 00 bV[ NNgbag>kvl_ĉ6R;NƖ-N(WT Tl0[Y8flKN-N $Nl;N/fNSOS,gvlQs^01u҉^egQ NNgbag>kvTl'` \N>yOb/gۏek0~NmSU\eb[vQۏLwQSOaϑ VdkSWezl[ NNgbag>kvĉ[/f_TSev0OncMRevRgbN:N [ NNgbag>kۏLSWelĉ6RvW,gzl`^/f;N{:gsQ N\vQĉ[:N~[Tlb~[ݏl /f9hncwQSO`QegRg[/f&TݏSNSWel0NbVb/gۏekT~NmSU\vW,gVV{QS [ NNgbag>kHeR[v~[S N)RNOۏb/g_ۏ0 OdTSU\ Oq_T\O:N~NmRRvzN;mR0VdkbN^zlvW,gb__/fNSWel\O:NSR'`c[ Q^wƋNCgSOS-NvSWel[eĉR\l_ĉ6Rvek0hQ~S0S_6q bN(WwƋNCgWSWelvgbl~QNN:Nzz}v 6R[[e~Rv^_'Y0NMRlpǏvv^ NS` sQ./f~bQeT0(WW,gzl`nx[T zl:gsQSNu+R'`0WPtVYvbq~ HQ\k gbcvRnx[ Neg [-NQek[U0Q NNgbag>kvSWelĉ6R[wƋNCg?eV{TzN?eV{vSS_Oea NN,vzlvk,geg1\O9e_f:NA~0@w?eV{vSSTSU\vBl ~TSl[-NQsv c[eSN[gb N[gO9e0gؚNllblQ^v$RO0Slʑ_NSN OS_@\v?eV{SS00 00 (2)gbl-Nl͑~y/}TRe0 00 Sl/fwQSOd\O'`v Nzlvk  l[@bb4NvTy>yOV }\/f[PNi Nvlf[[N`av [32]bV NNgbag>kvSWelSl[ T7hb4N@wg'YvV0vQN bVNvNbel\O:N͑vl_ nn l[:ON1uϑv~ yr+R/f NNgbag>kvzlwekZf gbl~1\fR k:0vQN [ NNgbag>kHeRvwQSO[S0R~NmTb/gSU\?eV{v:_'Yq_T Nl_ĉ[vk ?eV{SR'`'Y0fRup;m RgRN NNgbag>kgbl-Nv Nnx['`0vQ N bVzNlgbl:gsQ]\ONXTv }(oy NP NNgbag>kċNǏ z-N Nnx[vV }^8^ YBg KNvQ1uϑvzzǏ'YP`N܀N00 00 bN:NNt N㉳QُNv/fR'Y NNgbag>kgblvnx['` P[1uϑvV } @bNbV6R[vwƋNCgSOS-NvSWel[e~R^wQ gؚvfnx'`0HQ YgNgNagNkYSOSv{|W0Sev^:WNI{SNvc$Re NNgbag>kvSzN'` 1\ NQKN;N{:gsQRgwQSOSzNHegvCgR vc\vQ[:Nݏl0vQ!k Yg(W*NHh-NRg NNgbag>k[zNvwQSOq_T9vS_'Y 1\^S_Ǒ(u%Nk[gvv[V[v~g!j_0V:NbV\O:N;Nvb/gۏSV N)RSOSvSe__/f1_\vbVS_NN SWel[vQ)RvRN>PeOb0 N%Nkl_[vfzf b0_Sl-N[ NNgbag>kgbl~ gNN[y/}KNT 1\SNcRzlvSU\TO b_bo'`vNR00 00 ;` KN (Wzl N[ NNgbag>kvW,g`^/ffR[~gTup;m (WgbleRR[~bSnx['`V }N[sgbLǏ z-Nv~N0N Nv`S/f\O:N NNgbag>kĉ6RW,g!j_g^v_z @w~Rv Ne0Nn bV NNgbag>kvSWelĉ6RMbT[U00 00 0\O{N0 [z_ fkIl'Yf[lf[bYecNge& V[W0Wcw[b@\lQRXT0 0lʑ0 00 [1] V:NN)RCgasT@wv[%Nf s gb/g/fQ[e'`vsQ.00 00 [2] See Lear Inc. v Adkins 395 U.S.653 670(1969) 0 00 [3] William C.Holmle Intellectual Property and Antitrust Law Clark Boardman Company Ltd. pp.5N760l_ꁋsHQg 0wƋNCgNSWel wƋNCgn(uvSWexvz 0 l_QHr>y2001t^Hr ,{85u00 00 [4] STTV8SONVE8fNSc~SU\-N_ wƋNCgObNSc~SU\yvKN?eV{xvzcWS  0wƋNCgOb[SU\KN/T:yi 0 ,{3u http//www.unctad/org00 00 [5] T Ne ,{2u00 00 [6] STTV8fTSU\OyfNY(W,{V!kTTVhQb[g 0YOSvNWY{6RP6R'`FUN`OvlQs^SRTĉR 0O NvbJT 0zN?eV{TwƋNCgvLO 0 2000t^8g11e ,{23u http//www.unctad/org/en/subsites. 0 00 [7] _N1\/fbS_NNvT T1u YgNmS*NSO)Rv S_NNSN;N~[T Tag>k v^N NV:NbTSu[vQ N)Rv`b_ S`00 00 [8] SV 0wƋNCgyrOS-NvSXbbecWS 03.4 l_U^o;N 0wƋNCgxvz 0,{13wS -NVeckQHr>y2003t^Hr ,{330u00 00 [9] 00Jay Dratler Jr. 0wƋNCgS 0( N) s%fqI{ы nNS'Yf[QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{53uLear Inc. v. AdkinsHh-NLearlQSNN)ReHe\O:N N/eNO(u9vbt1u R)Ry<\Nؚ~lb(u SeybkS SR/ecN)RSeAdkins0lb:NSe N^S_(WNSSOS)Rvv TeS;N _\O:NOSW@xvN)ReHe0FO1969t^VTgؚlbcNُN$RQ [R[eHeN)RcQ_vT?eV{ON]T TlSRW@x NvybkS`SR00 00 [10] See William C. Rooklidge Licensee Validity Challenges and the Obligation to pay accrued RoyaltiesLear v.AdkindsRevisited (parta!) 69J. PAT [&TRADEMARK] OFF SOC Y5 pp. 89-90 (1987).0 00 [11] SUSSfIQ0RSfwm 0_V<S[P6RzNl>[wƋNCgST Tvc6R 0 }U^o;N 0wƋNCgxvz 0,{15wS -NVeckQHr>y2004t^Hr ,{178u00 00 [12] Se,g 0N)RTknowNhowSOS-NvSWelc[e 0eHr,g See,glQs^NfYXTOQz http//www.Jftc.go.jp /e-page/legislation /index.Html00 00 [13] SMR_ [3] sHQgfN ,{173u00 00 [14]  772/2004SagO ,{3agnxzNۏLAMQv^:WNWQ(marketNshare thresholds) [NzNKNvb/glOSSeS_NN(WvsQb/g^:WTNT^:WvTN NǏ20%v ^zNKNvOSS_NNT(WvsQb/g^:WTNT^:WvN NǏ30%v S(uagO,{2agKNAMQ00 00 [15] See Fiona Carlin & Stephanie Pautke The Last of its Kind The Review of the Technology Transfer Block Exemption Regulation 24NW.J.INT LL.&BUS.601(2004).0 00 [16] (W'kvNSOSvhv[sǏ z-N l_SO|]_TXWvmd/fg͑vekKNN0'kvVdk(WvQ:SW'`zle RR:NbXTVg^0R T7hl_TgvRg$Re!j_ Q\QsRgkHegT Nnx['`vS0(W[ NNgbag>kvĉ6RǏ z-N 'kvYXTO_N/f=\ϑ\SNfnxvhQV[ Neg )\gbl:gsQ1uϑvzz00 00 [17] SMR_ [11] USSfIQI{e ,{186u00 00 [18] SMR_ [8] V 0wƋNCgyrOS-NvSXbbecWS 04.200 00 [19] 8l:_ 0'kv2004t^0sQNb/glOS(uag~,{81ag,{3>kv772/2004SagO 0N~ 0 http//www.chinalawinfo.com00 00 [20] []Jay Dratler Jr. 0wƋNCgS 0( N) s%fqI{ы nNS'Yf[QHr>y2003t^Hr ,{53u00 00 [21] SMR_ [9] DratlerfN ,{513u00 00 [22] SMR_ [8] U^o;NfN ,{515uN N00 00 [23] OYFoster v.Hallco Mfg.Co. 947F.2d469 (Fed.CirN1991)Hemstreet v.Spiegel Inc. 551F.2d 348(Fed.Cir.1988)Diamond Scientific.Co. v.Ambico Inc. 848F.2d 1220(Fed.Cir.1988)I{0l_Christian Chadd Taylor No-Challenge Termination Clauses Incorporating Innovation Policy and Risk Allocation into Patent Licensing law 69 Ind. L.J. 215(1993). 0 00 [24] SMR_ [3] sHQgfN ,{138u00 00 [25] S4TIlN0__ 0eb_"NCg6R^xvz 0 l_QHr>y2005t^Hr ,{302u00 00 [26] SMR_ [9] DratlerfN ,{127u00 00 [27] SMR_ [15] Carlin & Pautkee00 00 [28] S<772/2004agO 0 tN ag>k(whereas clause),{5ag l_ _OT 0'kqQSO2004t^b/glOSAMQagON~ 0 http//www.tongji.edu.cn00 00 [29] SMR_ [9] DratlefN ,{81u00 00 [30] Christian Chadd Taylor No Challenge Termination Clauses Incorporating Innovation Policy and Risk Allocation into Patent Licensing law 69 Ind. L.J. 215(1993).:_'Yvnchf\ON g$N'YSVb:Nf}YvReُNONvxvzNXT8^[Θi gf:_v^'` NRe/fُNONۏN^:WT_bRvg}Ye_0See Panel Discussion The Value of Patents and Other Legally Protected Commercial Rights 53Antitrust.1.J.535 537(1984)0 00 [31] 8l:_ 0VEb/glT T-NvP6R'`ag>kSvQl_ĉ6R 0 http//www.chinalawinfo.com0 00 [32] ςR 0llSvQ,gWDn 0ꁏ^  0NHN/f`Ov!.s? 0 -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr ,{7u0 Pm*p,pFpHpZr\rxrzrttttuuwwwwzzzzd}f}}}HJFH҇ԇʍ̍4646BDКҚ ʻ̻hL hLo(Hwwzzzzd}f}}}HJFH҇ԇʍ̍gdL4646BDКҚ Xd,gdLΤ¦LҩT"`԰j$ε nηغZgdLZ̻gdL0182P. A!"#$%S N@N cke $1$a$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOBi@B nfh,?,L,M,----....00"0#0304011112222W4X4i4j4663646I6J66677h8i899::<<<<<<>>>>@@@@@@BB CC#D$D*F+FFFFFFFF;GrG HoHHIKIIJOKKL6LLxMN/NZNNNO7OPPPP#QQQSRSSr r r r e#r r r r r r  r r 1/r r @!r r  r r r r  r r r r @!r r @!r r r r r r :r r K)r r r r @!r r @!r r r r r r @!r r  r r e#r r F$r r  r r r r K)r r  r r |X-r r r r 5r r R*r r r r 1/r r R*r r r r L'r r r r @!r r F$r r r r r r L'r r r r b^0r r r r r r :r r r r K)r r r r 1/r r r r r r 5r r r r 1/r r r r 5r r r r @!r r r r r r r r r r  r r 1/r r 5r r :r r r r r r L'r r r r F$r r r r r r R*r r r r K)r r L'r r  r r r r r r r  r r  r r r  r r r e#r  r r r r  r r  r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r r  IJ;AOP()CDR S m n 7 8 67PQfg&'Z[qr~  '(de!!!!####w%x%^'_'m'n'''v)w)))+,,,>,?,L,M,----....00"0#0304011112222W4X4i4j4663646I6J66677h8i899::<<<<<<>>>>@@@@@@BB CC#D$D*F+FFFFFFFF;GrG HoHHIKIIJOKKL6LLxMN/NZNNNO7OPPPP#QQQSRSS00000000000000000H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0H0S 0SPm̻.^5VwZ̻/123_`ab̻0St=SS;*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagschsdate  1420087DayFalse IsLunarDate IsROCDateMonthYear &*,-/178;=ABCDEJ9;?CEFNR_bcz{',BGQ W X Y l p 6 :  6:5:OUVWel *+-=>@A  #'(+:;EFWY+/03DHILS^ !56X]`bfgY^} N[k"juvw}W[tx{~ &+,-cijk ~!!!!!!!!!!""""/"4"Z"["""""""######$$3$4$L$Q$$$$$q%{%%%%%#&'&7&<&X&^&d&h&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&]'c'd'e'l's'''Z(_(u)|)))))))* ***=*B***********+++++++++*,/,0,1,=,C,K,O,----....////S/X/0000!0'0206090A0001111E2J22222 4444V4]4h4m466268696:6H6L6R6U6z6~666666666666777.70777g8l8J9K999:: <<<<<<<<<<1=2=>>>>>?????)?+?@@@@@@BB CC?CDC"D'D)F.FFFFFFFFF:GJGKGYGZGeGfGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHH HHTHUHWH[H\H^HhHlHnHvH{H|HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHI IJIRIhIkI~IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII#J)JRJVJJJJJJJJKKKKK6K7K9KZSsStSSSSSSS HJ:;@CNR',BGQ V l p 6 : 5:OTej%*Y^pt} &*ch~!!!!####r%{%]'b'l'q'''u)z)))*,.,=,A,K,O,----....00!0%020600RSUSSS0RSSRSS5X x~~Y}>XZ,,,,RfB5X <P~DRfBXZ[Z[ZP~Dx~~LS@SStNSS@)S@@8@:@B@hUnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial;[SOSimSun 1hJѦJѦx G*x G*!-!),.:;?]}    & 6"0000 0 0 00000 =@\]^([{  0 0 00000;[aSaSHX?L2USERUSEROh+'0T    (4<DLUSERNormalUSER2Microsoft Office Word@@28r@28rx G՜.+,0 X`px CHINA*aS'   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry FPl?Cr1TabledDWordDocument2SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q